Skip to main content
Sister Publication Links
  • Automotive News
  • Automobilwoche
  • Automotive News Canada
  • Automotive News Mexico
Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • Newsletters
  • Login
  • HOME
  • News
    • Photos
    • Automakers
    • Suppliers
    • Sales By Market
    • Environment/Emissions
    • Latest Launches
    • Sales and Retail
    • Car Cutaways
    • On The Move
    • China's Baoneng boosts stake in Qoros
      Citroen says Ami One two-seater is a new concept for affordable mobility
      EU, Japan back automatic braking regulation
      German auto jobs at risk from hard Brexit
    • Driv spinoff to build smart suspension systems
      Faurecia hopes to outperform uncertain market
      Plastic Omnium posts strong results despite global production slump
      Sweden's Veoneer forecasts flat sales in 2019
    • Porsche, Alfa Romeo and Nissan take big hits as European sales fall 5% in January
      Russia sales rise nearly 1% in January despite VAT increase
      Audi, Fiat, BMW among losers as Spanish sales fall 8% in January
      Volvo, VW gain sales in UK market down nearly 2% in January as diesel plunge continues
    • Volvo blurs the wagon/SUV line with the V60 Cross Country
      view gallery
      7 photos
      New Range Rover Evoque designed for the 'urban jungle'
      Range Rover Evoque gets hybrid tech to cut emissions
      Tarraco gives Seat a flagship SUV to help retain wealthy buyers
    • Ferrari will unveil V-8 hybrid supercar this year
      Mercedes outsold Audi in China last month on sedan demand
      Tesla's Musk visits Norway to review delivery delays
      Europe's minicar segment to shrink as VW, PSA mull axing their smallest cars
    • Suppliers to the new Porsche Panamera
      Suppliers to the new Peugeot 5008
      Suppliers to the new Seat Ibiza
      Suppliers to the new VW Touareg
    • Ford names new chief government relations officer
      Daimler appoints Airbus exec as finance chief
      VW China CEO to join VW brand's management board
      Mini USA names marketing veteran McKenna head of product planning
    • Geneva Photo Gallery
    • Beijing Photo Gallery
    • Frankfurt Photo Gallery
    • Paris Photo Gallery
    • Shanghai Photo Gallery
  • Auto Shows
    • Geneva Auto Show
    • Frankfurt Auto Show
    • Paris Auto Show
    • Beijing Auto Show
    • Shanghai Auto Show
    • Aston Martin teases new hypercar ahead of Geneva debut
      Bugatti to unveil $18 million special edition named after Ferdinand Piech, report says
      Subaru Viziv Adrenaline concept to debut at Geneva
      Citroen says Ami One two-seater is a new concept for affordable mobility
    • Bugatti considers four-door model for 2024
      Frankfurt's best and wurst
      Frankfurt photo booth
      Merkel says German car industry must work to rebuild trust
    • Vietnam's first automaker now has names for first sedan, SUV
      Ferrari Monza supercars will earn $755 million in revenue
      China's GAC likely to debut in Europe with an EV
      Bugatti mulls SUV as part of broader model range
    • VW will launch SOL EV brand in China with subcompact crossover
      view gallery
      9 photos
      BMW's iX3 concept heralds electric expansion
      view gallery
      9 photos
      BMW will export iX3 electric SUV to Europe, U.S. from China
      view gallery
      11 photos
      Mercedes seeks to keep China luxury lead with stretched A class
    • view gallery
      7 photos
      Jeep finds green groove with plug-in hybrid SUV concept
      China's luxury market to grow to 3M a year, Audi, Mercedes predict
      view gallery
      10 photos
      Mercedes hints at new styling with sedan concept
      Foreign automakers embrace China as EV development hub
  • Opinion
    • Blogs
    • Luca Ciferri
    • Douglas A. Bolduc
    • Paul McVeigh
    • Is Honda's UK plant closure the beginning of a Japanese Brexit?
      Ford's 'redesign' for Europe emphasizes SUVs, LCVs
      Russia's Google, Yandex, impresses with its self-driving tech
      Renault Twizy gets new life in Korea as motorcycle replacement
    • Is Honda's UK plant closure the beginning of a Japanese Brexit?
      Ford's 'redesign' for Europe emphasizes SUVs, LCVs
      Russia's Google, Yandex, impresses with its self-driving tech
      Renault Twizy gets new life in Korea as motorcycle replacement
    • Is Honda's UK plant closure the beginning of a Japanese Brexit?
      Ford's 'redesign' for Europe emphasizes SUVs, LCVs
      Russia's Google, Yandex, impresses with its self-driving tech
      Renault Twizy gets new life in Korea as motorcycle replacement
    • Is Honda's UK plant closure the beginning of a Japanese Brexit?
      Ford's 'redesign' for Europe emphasizes SUVs, LCVs
      Russia's Google, Yandex, impresses with its self-driving tech
      Renault Twizy gets new life in Korea as motorcycle replacement
  • Maps
    • E-Car & Component Map of Europe
    • Powertrain Map of Europe
    • Assembly Plant Map of Europe
  • Supplements
    • Connected Car
    • Talk From The Top
    • BMW 100
    • Car Cutaways
  • EVENTS & AWARDS
    • Automotive News Europe Congress
    • Rising Stars
    • Eurostars
    • Leading Women
  • E-MAGAZINE
    • Read the latest issue
    • Download the app
    • Subscribe
  • More
    • E-Magazine
    • Contact Us
    • 2019 Media Kit
    • About Us
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. Automotive News Europe
November 03, 2014 12:00 AM

VW, Renault, GM, others bet big on megaplatforms

Ultra-flexible architectures sought to cut costs, gain edge on rivals

Christiaan Hetzner
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Print
    VW's MQB megaplatform allows it to set pre-defined dimensions and standardized interfaces for modules that can easily be swapped back and forth, lowering costs per unit and one-off r&d expenditure by as much as 20%.

    Mary Barra skipped Europe's biggest auto show of the year to focus on what is arguably her biggest strategic announcement so far as General Motors CEO. While other managers were in Paris last month, Barra briefed investors on her ambitious plan to reduce GM’s confusing slew of more than two dozen, largely integrated vehicle architectures to just four modular megaplatforms over the next 10 years.

    Like Volkswagen Group CEO Martin Winterkorn, Renault-Nissan boss Carlos Ghosn and Toyota chief Akio Toyoda, Barra knows that having prolific, flexible, globally compatible megaplatforms is a key to success in the fast-expanding, ultracompetitive volume car manufacturing business. Enormous economies of scale, lower development expenditure, faster times to market and the ability to build multiple cars on one line are some of the other mouthwatering benefits of megaplatforms. Mastering this part of the business could ultimately decide which automakers survive and which ones don’t as pressures from customers, competitors and regulators escalate.

    Two of Europe’s largest automakers, PSA/Peugeot-Citroen and Fiat Chrysler Automobiles, do not have global megaplatforms and analysts say that leaves them vulnerable in an industry in which bigger is often better, especially when it comes to procurement and establishing a worldwide presence. Also, by the time GM is finally finished with this mammoth platform revamp it will be 2025 -- the kind of distant future one might almost expect from science fiction movies given the auto industry’s current rapid pace of change. By then, it might be commonplace on European roads for people to be chauffeured around in self-driven cars powered by hydrogen fuel cells with only water vapor as exhaust.

    VW’s big head start

    Just as GM’s chief executive described her long-term vision, VW was busy making those dreams a reality and pocketing the savings for itself. It was ramping up production of its new Passat, already the sixth model line underpinned by the group’s ultraflexible modular transverse matrix, better known by its German acronym MQB.

    The race is on to find the most efficient and standardized megaplatform, the stakes are high and VW Group’s head start on its global competitors is substantial. Its MQB megaplatform puts it years ahead of rivals when it comes to the next evolutionary stage of mass car production. European competitors such as Renault-Nissan, PSA and Fiat Chrysler are rushing to catch up, shifting to a largely modular approach from a more integral one. But like with any strategic rollout that overhauls entrenched processes and disrupts business relationships, it entails big risks.

    “The bigger the platform the bigger the recall will be if there is a problem,” said Ernesto Antolin, vice chairman of Grupo Antolin, the industry’s largest supplier of vehicle headliners. “That is the bad side of supplying a megaplatform.”

    The reason Toyota’s massive, image-damaging recall in 2009-2010 was hard to contain was because it affected millions of vehicles made all over the world. In addition, VW’s launch of MQB, which is forecast to underpin nearly 6 million vehicles by 2020, has included a few bumps, although the carmaker has been able to contain them thus far.

    Photo

    Renault-Nissan says its three common module family (CMF) platforms will help cut purchasing costs as much as 30% and engineering costs by 40%.

    “Modularity is such a better way of thinking and acting and implementing than any other form of platform strategy,” said Luther Johnson of consultancy firm Modular Management. “But you can also say you’re doing it and do it poorly.” By breaking vehicles down to their lowest common denominator, VW is able to set pre-defined dimensions and standardized interfaces for modules that can easily be swapped back and forth, lowering costs per unit and one-off r&d expenditure by as much as 20 percent and engineered hours per vehicle by as much as 30 percent.

    Renault’s response

    Among the closest to achieving VW’s scale is Renault-Nissan. It aims to have 70 percent of its vehicles underpinned by three common module family (CMF) platforms for minicars (CMF A), subcompacts (CMF B) and compact/midsize (CMF C-D) models by 2020. At that time Renault-Nissan is expected to be making more than 3.5 million vehicles on CMF B, including the Renault Clio, and about 2.7 million cars using CMF C-D, including the Nissan Qashqai. This should cut purchasing and engineering costs by as much as 30 percent and 40 percent, respectively, the automaker says.

    Fiat Chrysler planned to have three megaplatforms with more than 1 million units by this year, but that target has been pushed back to 2018. The automaker believes the move will help it achieve 1.5 billion euros in cumulative savings.

    Not to be outdone, PSA wants to reduce its current platforms to two from seven by 2022. Last year the automaker launched the C4 Picasso and Peugeot 308 based on its new efficient modular platform (EMP2). PSA aims to launch 11 different models and build 1.5 million cars off EMP2 by 2018.

    “All the carmakers are working on this right now, I can’t think of anyone who is not, at least among the big names. It’s something that everybody has to do,” said Exane BNP Paribas auto analyst Stuart Pearson.

    But while they may be following the same goal, neither Fiat Chrysler nor PSA is expected to have one of the 10 largest global platforms by 2020, according to IHS Automotive forecasts. “PSA is a long way from the industry leaders -- in fact, the gap looks likely to only widen from here. We struggle to see how PSA can become competitive on costs until this issue is resolved,” Morgan Stanley wrote in a report last June. “Where PSA falls short is on its lack of absolute volume. Unfortunately this is harder to fix, and with organic growth hard to come by, may require further strategic alliances or M&A in our view.”

    ‘Late to the party’

    Even those carmakers with sheer scale such as GM, which despite its size still lags the competition in terms of rationalizing its platforms, cannot expect to see big benefits from the move to megaplatforms, experts say. Exane’s Pearson believes that in an industry where relative advantages are competed away quickly, laggards are motivated more by a defensive fear not to fall too far behind. “It’s like with any first-mover advantage whether it’s a hit model or a flexible architecture – the leaders tend to generate greater benefits and hang onto them longer than those that come late to the party,” he said.

    Photo
    AUTOMOTIVE NEWS EUROPE E-MAGAZINE

    This story is from the current issue of the Automotive News Europe monthly e-magazine, which is also available to read on our iPhone and iPad apps.You can download the new issue as well as past issues by clicking here.

    The rise of such modular architectures is no coincidence, since they are, in theory at least, the perfect answer to the dilemmas that the industry faces. Like its rivals, VW had been searching for a silver-bullet solution referred to as mass customization, in which it could meet demands for an increasingly diverse range of cars packed with connectivity, infotainment and a host of other driver assistance and safety features -- all at a low cost. At the same time VW needed to protect itself against severe pricing pressure and market volatility in Europe, tightening fuel-efficiency standards and an ever growing complexity in their production plants and supply chain.

    As a group, VW this year is on track to sell 10 million vehicles across a dozen brands, operate more than 100 different manufacturing plants and build more than 300 different models spanning from mainstream hatchbacks to heavy-duty commercial trucks. VW’s answer has been MQB, which uses modular “toolkits” to ultimately create more than 40 cars of different wheelbases, track widths, wheel sizes and seat positions. This allows it to leverage synergies not just horizontally across brands but vertically across entire segments from subcompacts all the way to midsize sedans. Previously, carmakers could not vary the basic dimensions of a car built off a specific platform, and only had the ability to put a different “top hat” onto the same chassis to differentiate models. So when VW completed the development in 2012, the company used words such as “milestone” and “quantum leap” to describe its ability to build cars of varying shapes and sizes with many of the same underpinnings so long as they shared one basic characteristic.

    By mounting engines transversely at exactly the same angle, VW can standardize key elements of a car, such as the exhaust line, driveshaft and transmission location and reduce the number of engine and transmission variations by about 90 percent. Two million cars, or one-fifth of VW Group volumes, will use MQB this year. “The number of MQB vehicles built will rise toward the 4 million mark in 2016. By then, the modular transverse toolkit will already be deployed in more than 20 plants in a dozen countries worldwide,” Winterkorn said.

    By creating a system of interchangeable building blocks, or modules, that share standardized interfaces, automakers can continually develop and optimize groups of components and subassemblies independent of one another. Executed properly, this approach lowers development costs, rationalizes the supply chain, reduces complexity, improves quality and speeds up time to market. The ultimate result is a model range that can be expanded with minimal effort to target high-demand segments, alternative powertrains or new niche derivatives that previously would not have been economically feasible.

    Margin improvement

    In a benchmark analysis of platform strategies, analysts at investment bank Macquarie did a rough calculation that carmakers could expect a 10 percentage point improvement in their operating margins by moving from a pure stand-alone platform strategy to a modular strategy.

    While rivals try to match VW with their own super-architectures, none of their megaplatforms are considered as ambitious, far-reaching and flexible. In theory any MQB car could be built in any MQB factory, helping smooth out uneven utilization rates across plants that lower profits. “The most important benefit, however, is also the most often overlooked. Modular toolkits essentially give flexibility to an OEM, including flexibility to switch between products and powertrains to meet peaks and troughs in demand, and flexibility to enter market segments with a lower break-even volume,” Morgan Stanley wrote.

    In truth, it’s not as revolutionary as Winterkorn says. Scania, now a unit of VW Group, introduced in 1980 a range of modular trucks with almost an unlimited number of variants. It paved the way for industry-leading profitability and is one of the cornerstones of its corporate philosophy to this day. More recently, modularity was a key part of the business model for Michael Dell’s personal computer company.

    “The concept [of modularity] has been around for a long time, but the automotive industry is a little slow to embrace it perhaps because the journey is a very difficult and challenging one,” Modular Management’s Johnson said.

    Unlike other management principles such as Toyota’s Kaizen where a company continuously improves existing best practices, modular production initially requires a radical rethink that affects everything from design and engineering to production, logistics and procurement. “You’ve got to bring the organization along with you. People tend not to like change and this operational challenge you have to overcome is not so obvious until you ask the engineering and purchasing managers to execute. You need to consider these unidentified ‘X’ costs of organizational disruption globally,” Justin Cox, a production expert at LMC Automotive, said.

    Mega-investment

    Considerable resources are needed as well. Morgan Stanley estimated that VW shelled out the eye-watering sum of 50 billion euros in development costs and capital expenditure to launch the MQB architecture – a fortune given VW targets a return on its investment of more than 16 percent in its core automotive business. “Modularity is a bigger upfront investment and if you look at the automotive industry they’ve got a lot of built-up inertia with their platform methodologies,” Johnson said. Rivals such as PSA, Renault and Fiat Chrysler that are still trying to emulate VW can take comfort knowing that it is still working out the kinks in the MQB system, and they can learn from their German competitor’s mistakes.

    Despite Winterkorn’s claims that initial positive effects from MQB are already being felt, the VW brand’s first-half operating margin narrowed to just 2 percent -- far below its target of more than 6 percent. Indeed, the CEO announced in July a 5 billion euro earnings improvement plan, which will likely include ditching cabriolets such as the VW Eos, outsourcing some component production such as brake discs, and eliminating superfluous options packages built into fewer than 5 percent of its cars. For example, there are some 156 different steering wheel variations offered in VW brand cars, which increases purchasing costs, makes assembly more time-consuming and requires more warehousing even though many are only differentiated by the color of the thread stitched into the leather.

    VW also suffered from line stoppages at its Wolfsburg plant when it integrated the MQB-based electric Golf into production, since the cars coming off the line were not meeting U.S. crash safety norms. Reuters cited witnesses who saw workers improvise by handing metal sheets to robots working on the e-Golf to stiffen its frame. “VW is pursuing ultimate scale yet they clearly haven’t really made that work for them at the moment and that’s the key investor frustration behind why the stock has underperformed over the last year or so,” Exane’s Pearson said. “To be fair they’re still ramping up and are nowhere near the full volume capability -- but MQB hasn’t delivered the savings people have been hoping for yet.”

    Conflicting views

    Extracting the potential savings from megaplatforms is more complex than merely getting more volume and models per platform or whether two or three architectures underpin 90 percent of overall production.

    Renault-Nissan’s Ghosn argues that savings are more tied to the geographic split of volumes, for example. “What is important is the scale in the region, because the scale in the region is going to determine your capacity to localize,” he told Automotive News Europe.

    Analysts are also split since the savings and their ultimate impact on earnings are difficult to model. Macquarie estimated VW can expect 7 billion euros in gross cost savings, or about 5 percent of its passenger car revenue, if the company doubled the volumes of each component through modularization. “However, this will be found in the bottom line only to a very small extent, maybe a third. The rest will be passed on to customers and will enable projects that would not be viable without the modular approach,” it wrote.

    Bernstein analyst Max Warburton is skeptical of the true benefits. Cars need to be built in multiple assembly plants on multiple continents, each with its own stamping presses, dies, welding automation, paint shops, tooling and local supply chains. “Where are the savings?” he asked. “VW’s MQB claims were nonsense from the start. Renault-Nissan and Toyota have come out with similar stuff but it’s mainly confined to their management’s PowerPoint presentations -- I don’t think many people internally believe the numbers,” Warburton added.

    Relaxed about recalls

    Increasing the number of shared components also raises the specter of massive recalls. When asked about this threat by Automotive News Europe’s German sister publication, Automobilwoche, a relaxed Winterkorn – who began his career as a quality guru – said it posed “no risk” so long as workers on shop floors maintained a watchful eye at all times.

    “They take all the components in hand innumerable times day after day. Our employees immediately see possible problems looming. And we encourage them to immediately set off the alarm and call out the problems,” he said in the interview.

    An assembly line worker spotting a hairline crack in a chassis control arm is one thing, but recognizing a design flaw of a component built into a Golf in Wolfsburg, a Passat in Emden and a Polo in Pamplona is another. It can take years before a faulty part is discovered. VW only recently was hit by a 1 million car recall to correct a potential problem with the rear suspension. “I think the benefits of platform scale are far more complex and harder to realize than a lot of the simplistic statements and goals suggest,” Bernstein’s Warburton said. “Put it this way -- I don’t think scale has much to do with PSA and Fiat’s financial struggles.”

    The benefits of mass customization outweigh the costs, however, and even premium carmakers such as BMW and Mercedes are following Audi’s lead and looking to scale up by ditching the far more integrated product architectures they preferred in the past.

    “The complexity in terms of the sheer breadth of different vehicles and various technologies that the customer expects from us can only be managed with a modular strategy and it’s our job that we utilize the chances it offers without exposing ourselves to the risks,” Daimler development chief Thomas Weber, told Automotive News Europe. “There is no alternative, we wouldn’t be able to manage in the future otherwise.”

    David Sedgwick, Douglas A. Bolduc & Luca Ciferri contributed to this report

    Monthly E-Magazine
    Thumbnail
    View latest issue
    See our archive
    Sign up for free newsletters
    EMAIL ADDRESS

    Please enter a valid email address.

    Please enter your email address.

    Please select at least one newsletter to subscribe.

    You can unsubscribe at any time through links in these emails. For more information, see our Privacy Policy.

    Get Free Newsletters

    Sign up and get the best of Automotive News Europe delivered straight to your email inbox, free of charge. Choose your news – we will deliver.

    You can unsubscribe at any time through links in these emails. For more information, see our Privacy Policy.

    Automotive News Europe Monthly E-Magazine

    Sign up to receive your free link to each monthly issue of Automotive News Europe as soon as it's published.

    GET THE E-MAGAZINE
    Connect with Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • Instagram

    Founded in 1996, Automotive News Europe is the preferred information source for decision-makers and opinion leaders operating in Europe.

    Contact Us

    1155 Gratiot Avenue
    Detroit MI  48207-2997
    Tel: +1 877-812-1584


    Email Us

    Resources
    • About us
    • Contact Us
    • 2019 Media Kit
    • Advertise with Us
    • Ad Choices Ad Choices
    • Sitemap
    Awards
    • Rising Stars
    • Eurostars
    • Leading Women
    Legal
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    Copyright © 1996-2019. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • HOME
    • News
      • Photos
        • Geneva Photo Gallery
        • Beijing Photo Gallery
        • Frankfurt Photo Gallery
        • Paris Photo Gallery
        • Shanghai Photo Gallery
      • Automakers
      • Suppliers
      • Sales By Market
      • Environment/Emissions
      • Latest Launches
      • Sales and Retail
      • Car Cutaways
      • On The Move
    • Auto Shows
      • Geneva Auto Show
      • Frankfurt Auto Show
      • Paris Auto Show
      • Beijing Auto Show
      • Shanghai Auto Show
    • Opinion
      • Blogs
      • Luca Ciferri
      • Douglas A. Bolduc
      • Paul McVeigh
    • Maps
      • E-Car & Component Map of Europe
      • Powertrain Map of Europe
      • Assembly Plant Map of Europe
    • Supplements
      • Connected Car
      • Talk From The Top
      • BMW 100
      • Car Cutaways
    • EVENTS & AWARDS
      • Automotive News Europe Congress
      • Rising Stars
      • Eurostars
      • Leading Women
    • E-MAGAZINE
      • Read the latest issue
      • Download the app
      • Subscribe
    • More
      • E-Magazine
      • Contact Us
      • 2019 Media Kit
      • About Us