Fiat Chrysler Automobiles filed a motion Friday to dismiss General Motors' racketeering lawsuit against the company.
In a sweeping suit filed in November, GM claims that its smaller rival secured an unfair advantage in labor costs by bribing UAW officials during key contract negotiations covering wages and benefits. The suit alleges that Sergio Marchionne, the late FCA CEO, wanted to hurt GM in an effort to force a merger between the two companies.
Marchionne, the suit says, "formally solicited GM for a merger" in the spring of 2015, an offer that was rejected. From there, the suit alleges that Marchionne orchestrated and negotiated a collective bargaining agreement that was "designed, through the power of pattern bargaining, to cost GM billions."
GM's suit also names three former FCA executives who have pleaded guilty in an ongoing federal corruption probe of top UAW officials. Federal officials say UAW leaders received payoffs from FCA officials starting shortly after the company was created in 2009.
FCA, citing "fatal flaws" and "hyperbolic assertions," laid out six points in a motion Friday that it believes makes the GM lawsuit worthy of dismissal.
Among them, FCA said the theory that it made concessions during 2015 contract talks to ding GM defies economic logic and did not "depend upon the alleged prohibited payments." FCA's motion says GM failed to adequately allege that it was a direct victim.
FCA said GM's RICO claims, "based on injuries allegedly incurred before Nov. 20, 2015 are time-barred under RICO's four-year statute of limitations because GM knew or should have known that its labor costs were higher than FCA's long before Nov. 20, 2015."
Going further, FCA's motion said "GM's RICO conspiracy claim should be dismissed because GM fails to allege an underlying RICO violation, and because a corporation cannot conspire with its own employees."
According to the motion, FCA's counsel "conferred with GM's counsel" on Jan. 9, 2020 in effort to get the case dismissed, but GM declined to voluntarily do so.
GM said Friday it remains confident in the legal and factual underpinnings of the case, which it said have already been documented in part through guilty pleas and admissions of FCA executives made in connection with the government's ongoing criminal probe of the UAW.
"Today's motion is no surprise," GM said in a statement. "It is a predictable tactic taken by the defendants, and we look forward to responding in court."